Just horrific. By my count, we returned 6 starters from a pretty good defense last year. That should be more than enough to not be the worst defense in FBS football. Yes, we are the worst defense in the FBS.
Last season, we only gave up over 400 yards 3 times. Our defense's worst game of the season was at Illinois, where we gave up 522 yards and 45 points. We have already given up more yards than that 4 out of 5 games this season and have only been able to hold 2 MAC schools under 40. Outside of Ohio State, none of the teams we have faced are any better than the teams we were playing last year.
This mess is ultimately on Tuberville's hands. At minimum, both defensive coordinators should be fired. If Tuberville's buyout is restrictive, then he gets at most one more season to prove why he shouldn't be sent packing as well. This program was built on hungry, up-and-coming coaches. Even if they used us as stepping stones, there is no denying that Dantonio and Kelly built up the program, and Butch Jones at worst didn't screw it up.
I really try not to overreact, but no good coach should have a defense this bad on his watch. Teams returning 6 starters on defense don't slide from 327 yds/gm and 22.0 pts/gm to 574 yds/gm and 40.8 pts/gm. 5 games is more than a large enough sample to determine the defense is a dumpster fire, and this one's on the coaches. Time to start over with a young coach who has something to prove.