Ugh, this is a such an over-used and ridiculous take. Cincinnati is a losing town, it's pretty hard to expect sports fans in this city to be constantly enthusiastic when our last championship was in 1990. Being a sports fan is inherently a fair weather gig. Rooting for a winning team is always going to be more exciting than rooting for a loser.
I have season tickets for football and I go to all the games but I couldn't sit here and tell you with a straight face that it's exciting or that I'm as emotionally invested in it as I was when we were winning. It's the nature of being a sports fan, calling a team or a city's fans fair weather is just ridiculous. Every fan is fair weather, it's not exclusive to UC or Cincinnati. Tell me another team in another city that consistently stinks yet plays games in front of sell out crowds on a regular basis.
Go Cats!