I think you're changing the story a lot when you talk about not winning any of our big OOC games. I think most of us would have agreed we needed to win at least 1 if not 2 between X, FLA, and UCLA. Tell me something. Let's say we don't win any of them (like your example above) but let's also say we replace 2 of our 300+ OOC wins with 2 top 150 wins. Do you really think the committee is going to be that much more impressed and shoot us up several seed lines? Not likely at all. Only if we added AND BEAT 2 more of their new Tier 1 games would it likely make much difference. Those are top 30 home games, top 50 neutral, or top 75 road games.
I think the subject (at the time) was about gaming the RPI by scheduling more teams in the top 150 range vs 300+. I don't think we are going to impress too many committee members with that kind of thing.
I think what your failing to see is the way our schedule is, its unlike any other top tier team this year. In Kenpom's top 30 teams, only 2 teams have a SOS of 300+: UC and Miami.
Miami is going to get to play duke, fsu, UNC, Louisville, Virginia, ND, NC State, Clemson, FSU, & Virginia Tech as top 50 games in the conference season. Its safe to say they don't have to worry about SOS.
We are in a non power league and we have a glaring SOS problem.
Instead of Alabama St we could have played a team like Old Dominion (#76), Instead of Savannah State we could have played a team like Mercer (#96), Instead of playing Coppin State we could have played a team like NKU (#91).
Those are all top 100 wins where we would win by 20-30 points that teams in our conference played this year. If teams in our conference can afford these buy games, we can too.
if we took off those 3 300+ games, and subbed them with those easily winnable top 100 buy games, were have insurance in case shit goes real bad against X, UCLA & Florida.
But we didn't. We have no insurance. And if we do lose all 3 (not out of the realm of possibility being as we are not home in any of those games) then all we have in the non conference is a really really bad SOS and just 1 top 100 win.
Like I said, I know it was not exactly UC's fault because of our arena. But its still a problem regardless. All the pressure in the world is on these next 3 games.
IMO Florida is the most important game on our schedule. Currently we have just 3 ranked games left on our schedule and I don't see any team in the AAC getting ranked this year. We don't win and its bad news. Be optimist all you want, but that is the reality. I've said this from the start