I agree there's more balance in the Big East too. It's balanced because it's a mix of mostly average to good teams. There doesn't seem to be a dominant team or two in the mix this year.
The bottom half of the American isn't good, but with teams like the Cats, UConn, Memphis, L'ville, and maybe SMU there seems like a chance someone in the conference could make a run in the tourney. Outside of Nova, I'm not sure the Big East has that at the moment.
I'm starting to see some similarities to X, St. John's and maybe a Seton Hall. They seem to snag great recruits but the promise isn't realized with team success. I think they have lost their team identity in the process. 4 and 5 star recruits are great, and I'm excited when the Cats get them. But I think Mick does a better job of targeting players that fit his vision for the team versus just signing anyone.