THIS. I always ask people "since the late 90s, who would you say our city's top 4 athletes are?" I think a common four would be Ken Griffey Jr, Kenyon Martin, Carson Palmer, and Joey Votto. What else do these four have in common? They've all been plagued by injuries; often at the worst possible times.
We as a city have been through a lot. Now that's not to say that other city's haven't, but factor in those devastating injuries while knowing the Reds/Bengals are a combined 0-9 in games that would send them to the next round since 2005 is gut-wrenching. Just on sheer odds, that's unbelievably unlikely. We are a city with teams that have either been abysmal, or teased us into thinking we're good, only to get our hearts ripped out very early in the postseason.
I'm pretty darn optimistic about my teams, but everything I've mentioned makes it VERY difficult. For the record, I'm 25, so the only "glory days" I have are Huggins consistent 2nd round exits, which were also quite heart-breaking.