A couple of things to add here. (1) They didn't really have 5*/4*/3* rankings back then, but they did have traditional player rankings through publications like HoopScoop, Street & Smiths and Basketball Times. (2) 5* rankings usually captures players ranked 1-25/low 30s.
Remember, Huggins got "5-Star-ish" talent via Transfer as well...
LaZelle Durden - Top 40 player Basketball Times '91
Dontonio Wingfield - McDonald's All-American/Consenus Top 10 Player
Keith Legree - Transfer/McDonald's AA/Consensus Top 20 Player
Damon Flint - McDonald's AA/Consenus Top 15 Player
Danny Fortson - McDonald's AA/Consenus Top 15 Player
Darnell Burton - HoopScoop Top 35 Player
Ruben Patterson - #1 JUCO
D'Juan Baker - JUCO/McDonald's AA at Arlington Martin High
Pete Michael - #1 JUCO
Eugene Land - Consensus Top 30 Player
DerMarr Johnson - McDonald's AA/Consensus Top 3 Player
Kenny Satterfield - McDonald's AA/Consensus Top 10 Player
Jerome Harper - NEVER PLAYED/McDonald's AA/Consensus Top 20 Player
James White - TRANSFER/McDonald's AA/Consensus Top 20 Player
Robert Whaley - JUCO/5* out of high school/#1 JUCO
Devan Downey - Consensus Top 35 Player
Roy Bright - Consensus Top 40 Player
Several more guys right outside Top 30 and in the 30-65 range
Cronin:
Lance Stephenson
Jermaine Lawrence
Mike Wiliams - TRANSFER/McDonald's AA/Consensus Top 20 Player