Being at square 1 is a reality every year. You have to make the tourney to do well in the tourney. Define your idea of a successful program.
We have had some success. I am not a Mick basher. My idea of a successful program includes being able to perform in the dance. A great coach should be able to step it up a notch in March...not step it down a notch.
As I said...he needs to make a run and then validate in a reasonable time frame for me to give him the keys to the program for life. He has enough years under his belt (15) that he should be able to learn by now how to get more out of his team on the biggest stage. 8 straight trips with little to show.