Two totally different cases- Thomas is just undersized, Sanders couldn't keep up with the pace of the game. I guess I can see the argument for not redshirting Sanders, but I think that either JD3 or Sanders should've been redshirted. We needed Guyn because he is our backup pg, but I think that we still had an abundance of guards last year and could've afforded to redshirt one of the two. I guess you never know when it would be nice to have extra players (see brawl, UC-XU). Since we sometimes struggled shooting the 3 ball, JD3 is nice to have, leaving Sanders as the player to redshirt. While I know nothing compares to actually playing in a game, you can still gain a lot by practicing with the team, learn the offense/defense, lose some weight (in his case) in the weight room. SK said that it helped him out tremendously and Mick acknowledged that not redshirting Sanders was one of his worst decisions last year.