Savannah State

BearcatTalk

Help Support BearcatTalk:

waterhead said:
A lot of people were thinking redshirt early on. I don't recall anyone thinking injury was going to get him there. Maybe you can point to his posts predicting the injury and the subsequent redshirt?
Click to expand...

Everyone said redshirt before the season I said it after the season had started
 
cincyguy13 said:
Has anyone other than this message board said it was medical? Can u point to this
Click to expand...


who cares? Redshirt was a hot topic with him. Why do you think some other fan had a copyright on it. It's ridiculous. I was one of them. Go back...I was a huge proponent of it.

We were all asking why play him if you want to redshirt him. Bearcatboy offered NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO reasons ever. Injury is a reason.
 
waterhead said:
who cares? Redshirt was a hot topic with him. Why do you think some other fan had a copyright on it. It's ridiculous. I was one of them. Go back...I was a huge proponent of it.

We were all asking why play him if you want to redshirt him. Bearcatboy offered NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO reasons ever. Injury is a reason.
Click to expand...

The difference is you said before the season, I said after the season started. I’m right your wrong go cry somewhere else
 
Bearcatboy said:
Injury has nothing to do with what I said
Click to expand...

You can't ask for a redshirt mid season because you think it might be nice.

Redshirt Rules. For an athlete to receive a standard redshirt, the NCAA requires that player not be involved in any competition for the year he is redshirted. Any amount of competition time, even 1 minute on a basketball court during a regular season game, for example, counts as a season of eligibility.


Suggesting you might have predicted injury is just laughable.
 
waterhead said:
You can't ask for a redshirt mid season because you think it might be nice.

Redshirt Rules. For an athlete to receive a standard redshirt, the NCAA requires that player not be involved in any competition for the year he is redshirted. Any amount of competition time, even 1 minute on a basketball court during a regular season game, for example, counts as a season of eligibility.


Suggesting you might have predicted injury is just laughable.
Click to expand...

Again I said redshirt he is redshirting.
 
waterhead said:
You can't ask for a redshirt mid season because you think it might be nice.

Redshirt Rules. For an athlete to receive a standard redshirt, the NCAA requires that player not be involved in any competition for the year he is redshirted. Any amount of competition time, even 1 minute on a basketball court during a regular season game, for example, counts as a season of eligibility.


Suggesting you might have predicted injury is just laughable.
Click to expand...
This is what I was getting to. If anyone knew the actual rule. It use to be a certain percentage of games played.
 
Who would have thought that the Savannah State game thread would have lasted this long?
 
Bearcatboy said:
Mick ain’t stupid he doesn’t have playing time of course he’s “ injured “
Click to expand...

You NEVER said any of this at all (at the time) but now imply you knew it all along...lol! Just ridiculous.

Why didn't you say it if you thought it? Because either you didn't have the balls or you weren't thinking it at all. I am not sure which one is right.
 
waterhead said:
You NEVER said any of this at all (at the time) but now imply you knew it all along...lol! Just ridiculous.

Why didn't you say it if you thought it? Because either you didn't have the balls or you weren't thinking it at all. I am not sure which one is right.
Click to expand...

I’m saying he is redshirting he may or may not be injured and one can say someone is injured if you don’t have playing time for them. Find me the rules where you have to send the NCAA the X-rays or whatever you need in order to get a medical redshirt, because I’m pretty sure if you have played some garbage minutes and get “injured” and have no playing time why not save a year of eligibility?
 
waterhead said:
You NEVER said any of this at all (at the time) but now imply you knew it all along...lol! Just ridiculous.

Why didn't you say it if you thought it? Because either you didn't have the balls or you weren't thinking it at all. I am not sure which one is right.
Click to expand...

I did I said he would redshirt after the season had started...
 
I was not defending Bearcatboy. I would never do that for obvious reasons. Want to make that clear. Just wanted to know the rule
 

Similar threads

J
Game by Game Predictions:
Replies
12
Views
15K
Alum2013
A
J
Looking at the Non Conference Opponents
Replies
7
Views
4K
cincyguy13
C
J
Very Early AAC Preview
2 3
Replies
44
Views
17K
jacobkdoyle
J
D
Town Hall Meeting
Replies
7
Views
5K
david aka the TYZ
D
B
What Big 12 Expansion Should Look Like
Replies
7
Views
5K
Bearcat1234
B
Back
Top