Fwiw, Cronin handled the Xavier situation poorly IMO.. Gates actions were totally malicious and should have been booted from the team. The penalties were laughable and I don't know a college bball fan outside of the Cincy fans like yourself that met it with "positive applause". Not one...
You might want to do some research on precedents set for that kind of situation (believe it or not, it wasn't the first--or even the worst--brawl to occur in college basketball), the suggestions that other schools' presidents/athletic directors made (not sure if SJU was specifically involved here or not), the opinions of Big East officials, how UC's president, athletic director, and Cronin went about figuring out the parameters of the suspensions, read/watch more of the background of the players involved, read about how Cronin made numerous attempts to prevent the situation before it happened, learn the added requirements that each suspended player had to satisfy besides just sitting out games, watch the entire sequence of events in that game before, during, and after the fight, remember that you'd have to handle the situation from the role of teacher/mentor not just coach/punisher while trying to create a good future for these college kids, etc.