In comparing Huggins and Cronin (in terms of recruiting) it may get a little hairy since Cronin was under Huggins for a time and Cronin was handed a hot mess to start. But to say we endured the same type of recruiting under Huggins I would probably disagree. Of those you won't see on the above link which dates back to 98 for top recruits and at least 1984 for MCD's AA's you won't find these guys. I don't know where they were ranked but I am guessing there are some 4 star guys here...and I am also leaving a few out I am sure.
Martin
Van Exel
Blount
Buford
Williams
Burton
Patterson
Durden
Levett
Bobbit
Kirkland
Little
Long
Logan
Mickeal
Brannen
Gregor
Jones
etc...
I understand many were jucos (and a couple were transfers) and it was a different time back then for jucos but the point is Huggins was able to land them. This list is not to denegrate Cronin because I am very happy we have him...I just think we should be better at getting some higher ranked recruits (specifically higher ranked 4 star guys) and the excuses for what Cronin was handed are getting old now. If we look at 2012 and 2013 I can tell you I DO like Rubles, Nyarcuk, Johnson, and Caupain...but I don't think any are inside the concensus top 100 which would denote a 4 star type of guy. I would rather see more top 75 guys because they are the sure fire type 4 stars and 5 star kids.
I would guess Huggins may have landed 3 times as many 4-5 star guys. Cronin's 3 best recruits (in terms of rankings inside the top 75) were Gates, Stephenson, and McClain and the last was in '09. So we haven't seen one top 75 guy in 2010, 2011, 2012, and so far 2013. I understand the issues of his early tenure...but when you look at it...he had success back then. My problem is recruting isn't getting noticeably better now that our program is standing on firm ground.
He may be getting "system guys" and "4 year guys"...but that's not because he isn't going after the higher ranked kids. We just aren't getting them.
Good write up, very well done. I would like there to be more highly regarded recruits as well. One thing I would say is we are in on much better recruits and much more recruits than we were a couple years ago. It's going to take some time before kids want to come here simply because its Cincinnati. Face it: The guys were recruiting were about 9 years old when huggins was here. They don't think of us as a former powerhouse that is coming back. We are simply the new team on the block that's had a couple successful seasons. Hard to convince a top talent to come here running on that.