I think Shaq Thomas before he leaves Cincinnati, will be a very good player. He still needs to get a consistant jumper though. Teams, especially this year, with our style of play, will fall back on defense and play zone to prevent the drive. The floor with Thomas is a moderately good sf, he packs on strength and gets a jump shot, he has the potential to be a lottery kid.
On the up side: Explosive athleticism, knows how to make smart passes in tight spots and has a great handle, for a guy his size.
On the down side: He's rail spike thin and will be physically man handled in the wrong place. He has to get a reliable jumper and then make it reliable beyond the arc. He's also never seen higher tier or any tier, for that matter, NCAA competition.
That's how I see it, anyway. A more mature body, he would have been a 5 star, rather than a 4.